7 Tips for a Profitable Garage Sale (2024)

7 Tips for a Profitable Garage Sale (1)

There are now more ways than ever to get cash for your unwanted stuff. You can take things to consignment stores, sell on eBay or Craigslist or use any number of direct selling apps on your phone. But when you want to sell a lot of diverse items quickly, you still can’t beat a good old-fashioned garage or yard sale. And if you’re going to go through the work of putting it together, you want to come out richer at the end. Here are 7 tips to help make your next garage sale or yard sale as profitable as possible.

Offer Plenty to Sell

A sparse garage sale doesn’t have much curb appeal. Treasure hunters are looking for a good reason to stop, so give them many! When considering items to sell, just about anything goes. Along with clothing and household goods you’ve grown tired of, include things like leftover craft supplies, cans of paint, spare auto parts, tools, books & magazines, kids’ toys & games, and sports equipment. You never know what someone might be looking for and be thrilled to find. Remember, one person’s trash is another person’s treasure.

Spruce Things Up

Obviously, customers won’t be expecting items to be in like-new condition, but they should be clean and presentable. Once you’ve decided what you’re selling, spend some time preparing it for sale. Clothing and shoes should be clean and fresh-smelling, small appliances should be free of spots and spills, and furniture should be dusted and ideally, polished. The more appealing your items are, the more you will sell. Don’t put anything out for sale that you wouldn’t want to purchase yourself.

Make it Easy to Shop

Group items together in a logical way to make shopping easier. Clothing, shoes and accessories together in one area. Books, magazines, DVDs and CDs in another, tools and DIY supplies in another, and so on. Garage sale fans love the thrill of the hunt, but you can make their search easier by creating common-sense groupings of similar products.

Don’t Price Too High … or Too Low

Pricing garage sale items can be tricky. Price items too high, and you’ll lose casual browsers. Price them too low, and you take away the opportunity for die-hard bargain hunters to haggle. While there’s no set rule for pricing, think about what you realistically would be willing to pay for the same item in its current condition. And speaking of pricing, be sure prices are clearly marked on items. If you just can’t take the time to price each item individually, create large, clear signs with prices for each type of product, i.e. ‘All Books, $1.00,’ ‘All Clothing $2.00’ etc.

Remember that Time is Money

It might seem counter-intuitive, but you’ll get more bang for your buck if you limit your sale to a day or, at most, a day-and-a-half. You’ll be busiest and make the majority of your sales on the first day when inventory is highest. Dragging it out over multiple days just creates a lot of work with little chance for real profit past the first day.

Draw Customers with Freebies

Nothing sparks interest like the word ‘FREE.’ Keep a box clearly marked ‘free’ about halfway up the driveway and fill it with odds n’ ends you don’t mind giving away for nothing. Think random items like extra ear buds, old cell phone chargers, broken costume jewelry, or cracked dishes. Crafters, collectors and DIY enthusiasts can find a use for just about anything, and once they’re drawn in to check out the free stuff, they’ll likely make a purchase.

Offer Profitable Extras

Whether you make them yourself or pick them up from Costco or Sam’s Club, selling snacks and drinks during your garage or yard sale can take your final total over-the-top. It doesn’t have to be fancy; cookies, snack bags of chips and bottled water will sell really well. Hungry shoppers won’t think twice about shelling out a few bucks for a snack and drink to keep them going.

7 Tips for a Profitable Garage Sale (2024)

FAQs

How do I make my garage sale successful? ›

How to Hold a Successful Garage Sale
  1. Don't wait until the last minute. ...
  2. Contact your local government. ...
  3. See if neighbors want to join in. ...
  4. Schedule the sale. ...
  5. Advertise. ...
  6. Price your goods. ...
  7. If it's junk, recycle or donate it. ...
  8. Display items nicely.

How do you attract customers to a garage sale? ›

Start posting online ads and hanging flyers, and a few days before the sale, tell everyone you know about it in person and on your social media. Call it something catchy but simple, such as "Shannon's Huge Sale!" or "Friends' Ultimate Group Sale!" so your sale stands out.

How to make extra money at a garage sale? ›

Offer Profitable Extras

Whether you make them yourself or pick them up from Costco or Sam's Club, selling snacks and drinks during your garage or yard sale can take your final total over-the-top. It doesn't have to be fancy; cookies, snack bags of chips and bottled water will sell really well.

What is the best day for a garage sale? ›

Friday, Saturday and Sunday mornings are usually the best time to hold a successful garage sale. Consider scheduling your sale on the first weekend of the month—when people have just gotten paid and haven't spent all their fun money yet.

How can I increase sales in my garage? ›

4 Tips to Get More Customers For Your Garage Business
  1. Create a Website. ...
  2. Integrate a Garage Management System. ...
  3. Use Local Advertising, Digital Marketing and Social Media. ...
  4. Focus On Providing Quality Service. ...
  5. Choose TechMan's Garage Management System For Better Efficiency and Revenue.
Nov 1, 2022

What is the best weekend for a yard sale? ›

As you likely guessed, Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays are known as the best time to have a yard sale because that's when most people can attend. What is yard sale season, though? It's usually the spring and summer because of favorable weather conditions.

What is the most popular garage sale item? ›

12 Garage Sale Items That Sell Like Hotcakes
  1. Gently used clothing, in good condition. Everyone needs clothes, and savvy shoppers know you don't have to pay retail to look good. ...
  2. Tools. ...
  3. Furniture. ...
  4. Vintage dishes, glassware, and casseroles. ...
  5. Garden tools. ...
  6. Shoes and handbags. ...
  7. Costume jewelry. ...
  8. Games, toys, and bicycles.

How do you display things at a garage sale? ›

Best to put everything on a table or hang it within reach. Dumping clothes on a sheet on the lawn, only looks like you haven't done laundry in a long time. Clean it, dust it or at least wipe it down. If it's clean and tidy it sells a LOT faster.

How to price jewelry for garage sale? ›

Books 25 cents to 50 cents for paperbacks and $1 for hardbacks. Jewelry is usually priced 25 cents to $3, but if you've got some fine jewelry, it would be worthwhile to check out a reputable jewelry store that purchases gold and silver.

How can I make extra money in my garage? ›

Did you know you can rent garage space to others and earn extra money? You can renovate a garage into an apartment and charge monthly rent or give someone space to store furniture and knick-knacks that no longer fit in their home. You can even offer daily parking spots if you live in a prime city location.

Can you use Venmo for garage sales? ›

Although cash has long been the currency of garage sales, in this day and age, you'll likely get more bang for your buck if you also accept digital payments. Open up Venmo and/or PayPal accounts, and consider using payment services like Square or Stax.

How to make a garage sale successful? ›

Advertising is essential to a successful garage sale. If people don't know about it, they can't possibly come and shop. Make sure to put up plenty of signs! If your kids enjoy being crafty this is where you'll want to get them involved!

What are the disadvantages of a garage sale? ›

Another significant downside is that a garage sale is a lot of work. Successful garage sales involve (and require) a lot of preparation like making signs, placing ads, getting permits, pricing items, and getting up before dawn on the day of the sale to set everything up.

How much cash should I have for a garage sale? ›

Choose a date, gather items to sell, and organize them in a way that makes browsing easy for buyers. Sometimes I've started with only $30 but always make sure and have the 10 $1 bills because a lot of people will buy a one or two dollar item and give you a five.

How to display items at a garage sale? ›

Best to put everything on a table or hang it within reach. Dumping clothes on a sheet on the lawn, only looks like you haven't done laundry in a long time. Clean it, dust it or at least wipe it down. If it's clean and tidy it sells a LOT faster.

How to price clothing for a yard sale? ›

Specific Garage Sale Pricing: How to Price Items for a Garage Sale
  1. T-shirts, tank tops, and basic tops: $1 – $5.
  2. Jeans, pants, and shorts: $3 – $10.
  3. Dresses and skirts: $5 – $15.
  4. Jackets and coats: $5 – $20.
  5. Shoes: $3 – $15.
  6. Accessories (hats, scarves, belts, etc. ): $1 – $5.
Dec 5, 2023

How can I promote my garage sale online? ›

Where to post garage sale ads online. Today, there many free online resources available to advertise your garage sale. Sites like YardSaleSearch.com, Gsalr.com and GarageSaleFinder.com—and their mobile apps—enable garage sale enthusiasts to browse sale listings and even map out a route of their favorites.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: The Hon. Margery Christiansen

Last Updated:

Views: 6295

Rating: 5 / 5 (70 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: The Hon. Margery Christiansen

Birthday: 2000-07-07

Address: 5050 Breitenberg Knoll, New Robert, MI 45409

Phone: +2556892639372

Job: Investor Mining Engineer

Hobby: Sketching, Cosplaying, Glassblowing, Genealogy, Crocheting, Archery, Skateboarding

Introduction: My name is The Hon. Margery Christiansen, I am a bright, adorable, precious, inexpensive, gorgeous, comfortable, happy person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.